rssMan is always more than he can know of himself; consequently, his accomplishments, time and again, will come as a surprise to him. - Golo Mann
2007, October 27
Another Cross Relation
Another cross or false relation in BWV 248.5
Another example of a 'false' cross relation in measure 12 in a chorale from BWV 248, the Christmas Oratorio.
Listen to the illustration
View entire chorale
Listen to entire chorale
The C sharp in the alto part followed by an C natural in the soprano part in the illustration above would seem to fit all the criteria for a false or cross relation.
But, again the C sharp is at the end of a phrase, and the C natural is at the beginning of the next phrase.
So, once again, I don't think this qualifies as a true cross relation.
Page 1 of 1 pages
